by
xusia
@ 03/06/2008 - 20:43:13

Spoiler Warning.
I have included some plot details in this review that may spoil "Indiana Jones & the Kingdom Of The Crystal Skull" for those who have not yet seen it. Please be aware of this before reading. XoD.
Well it's finally arrived after 19 years. I won't bother with an in depth plot breakdown as there has been more than enough of these in the last two weeks. Most fans and even the casual viewer will be familiar with the thrust of the plot by now. It is this media overkill and the recent phenomena of documenting every aspect of a film production via the internet, prior to it's release, that has led to the polarised expectations and views we've seen.
Hollywood is an industry that regularly resurrects franchises. If in doubt, revisit a tried and tested formula. Public good will and nostalgia will often guarantee decent box office returns. Sometimes this works as with Christopher Nolan's "Batman Begins" and Bryan Singer's "Superman returns". Often these fail. Take "I Spy", "Starsky & Hutch", "The Dukes Of Hazard", and some may argue the latter 3 "Star Wars" prequels. It often comes down to a trade off between pleasing existing fans and trying to capture a new market who may not be familiar with the original material.

Despite the familiar faces, music, production team and many other common elements to previous entries, IJATKOTCS suffers from a weak screenplay. New characters are introduced but none have sufficient back story. The fact that these roles are carried by quality actors helps, but they are not used to the best of their potential. Action scenes are punctuated with perfunctory plot exposition and the major plot element of aliens bears the clumsy handiwork of Mr. Lucas. It was he who allegedly vetoed scripts from several respected writers, including Frank Darabont.

Despite my reservations, Spielberg handles the relationship between Shia Lebouf and Harrison Ford very well. Some of the better scenes and dialogue is the banter between the two, focusing very much on the "old" and the "young". The female characters do not fair so well. Karen Allen is not given enough to do, which is a shame as her character was integral in ROTLA. Kate Blanchett is rather imposing as the Russian villain. Equipped with borderline psychic powers and a penchant for fencing, you'd think she'd be a standout feature of the film. Alas, again there is not enough material to flesh out the role.

It's difficult to find the correct balance between narrative and action as these films are essentially big budget "B" movies and cliffhanger serials. It's what the public expects. However, in this film I believe there is a little too much emphasis on action and I suspect the culprit is once again Mr. Lucas. Don't get me wrong there are some good scenes featuring traditional physical stunts The motorbike chase is a very good example with a rather amusing payoff. There is also the signature fist fight with the heavy of the movie. But then there are a few scenes that cross over the line and strain the viewers sense of credibility even by genre standards. You'll know them when you see them. Also, Indy's whip is under used which is a shame as other signature traits are present.

Now considering all that been said so far, you may well assume that I did not enjoy IJATKOTCS. But, this is not the case. Despite my criticisms Spielberg has succeeded in reviving a great character and franchise. This film is still streets ahead of the competition. This is largely down to the star quality of Harrison Ford and the skill of the director. There is still a lot to like about this film. Superb production design, excellent score, beautiful cinematography, superb editing and a character that everyone can identify with. The transition from the 1930's to the 50's works very well. The nuggets of information we get about what Indy's been up to in the last 20 years are rather intriguing. Working for O.S.S. and becoming a decorated war hero for example.The anecdote about Roswell raises a wry smile.

If you recognise that this is more of the same, rather than a totally fresh outing for the Jones's, then you'll probably enjoy the film a lot more. It's the cinematic equivalent of going to a favourite restaurant and ordering the meal that you usually have. It may not offer any surprises, but you know what to expect and the have the satisfaction of enjoying something familiar and pleasurable.
XoD.