Join now!

Search blog.co.uk

The Hobbit (1977).

by xusia @ 21/08/2008 - 19:05:32

I remember reading an article about this animated TV production, in Starburst Magazine during the late 70's. There were rumours that this Rankin/Bass production, which had already premièred on US network television, would gain a European cinema release. This was possibly to cash in on the success of Ralph Bakshi's animated feature film adaptation of "The Lord Of The Rings". However, this never happened and to my knowledge "The Hobbit" has never been commercially released in the UK via any medium. In the US, it has been available on two VHS labels and also on DVD.

The Hobbit1

The production company had a pedigree in bringing traditional and familiar children's material to the small screen, so it was not unusual for them to take on such a project. However, the major animation was sub contracted to a Japanese studio and subsequently had a major impact on the production design. Rankin/Bass productions often included songs in their material and Tolkien's work lent itself to this very well. As a result "The Hobbit" has a wealth of vocal tracks sung by popular folk singer, Glenn Yarbrough.

The Hobbit3

The adaptation of the story is very simple. Some of the more complex plot details have been lost, such as the Arkenstone, Beorn and the scheming master of Lake Town. Tolkien wrote this story for children and that is the way the film is pitched. The character designs range from the adequate to the bizarre. Gandalf is represented pretty much as you would expect. Bilbo and the Dwarves reflect a more juvenile friendly interpretation. However, the Trolls and Goblins are not especially scary and lack any real sense of threat. It is in the design of the Elves that this production really fumbles the ball. This race of near perfect creatures with their angelic qualities, are simply ugly and emaciated. Someone definitely missed the point! Gollum is also poorly conceived and looks a little like a large Bullfrog.

The Hobbit2

With these shortcomings, are there any positive attributes regarding this production? Well the minimalist water colour backgrounds work well, often drawing on Tolkiens illustrations themselves. The voice casting has some strong performers, such as John Huston as Gandalf. However, some of the minor characters are played by well known voice artists Don Messick and John Stephenson as a result you do feel that you are watching an episode of "Scooby Doo" or "The Arabian Night".

The Hobbit4

So where does this leave us? Well it's difficult to be objective as any adaptation of Professor Tolkien's work will be over shadowed by the success of Peter Jackson's trilogy. A lot of this was due to his use of several well known artists as production designers. The public already au fait with their work and visual interpretation had no difficulty in accepting Jackson's vision. "The Hobbit" suffers as a result of this. It is a low budget, basic adaptation, with a variety of good and bad animation. The biggest stumbling block being the design of the character. They are often not as you and I would envisage them.

For your enjoyment, here are several songs from the film soundtrack. The vocals are by Glenn Yarbrough and the film cast.

1.) "The Greatest Adventure".

2.) "The Dwarves Song".

3.) "That's What Bilbo Baggins Hates".

4.) "The Road Goes Ever On And On".

XoD.

Trackback address for this post:

authimage

Comments, Trackbacks: Hide subcomments

Devilish_Jelly_BeanzDevilish_Jelly_Beanz [Member]
2008-08-21 @ 20:06

Wow that looks good....and am i seeing things or does Smoug have the head of a cat???

xusiaxusia pro
2008-08-21 @ 20:45

He does indeed have a very feline looking head. It's been commented on by many fans. The voice was supplied by actor Richard Boone and he does give it a good go, so to speak.

XoD.

SeasideManSeasideMan pro
2008-08-21 @ 20:07

Interesting review, thanks. I've never seen this film and probably never will. The book meant a lot to me when I was a kid and the film can only ruin my visuals of it. I'll go and see the new Hobbit film when it eventually comes out, though I might be peering through my fingers in bits of it.

Tom.

xusiaxusia pro
2008-08-21 @ 20:52

Yes, I know what you mean. I when I first saw this film, I was both shocked and enthralled due to the bizarre visuals etc.

I did the same to a lesser degree to Ralph Bakshi's animated version of TLOTR. Boromir, for example is poorly depicted, like a cheap viking which the "Men of Gondor" certainly weren't

Oh, and if think this is weird, Rankin/Bass saw a gap in the market and when United Artists decided not to make Bakshi's proposed second half of TLOTR.

So they made a sort of sequel themselves "The Return Of The King". It was based on the last book of the trilogy, but skimmed over most aspects of the plot. It was deigned in the same style as "The Hobbit" and features disco dancing Orcs!

I have a few screen captures and will post one in "My media" section. Check it out and be confused, shocked and stunned!
XoD.

SeasideManSeasideMan pro
2008-08-21 @ 20:57

Gosh, I didn't know that ROTK even existed. I just looked it up on IMDB and it looks hideous!

Tom.

ABE-unlimitedABE-unlimited pro
2008-08-21 @ 21:09

I don't think I will watch that, but I must tell you I enjoyed reading "Hobbit" a bit more than I did "the LOrd of the Rings". I know it sounds like a heresy but I had this affinity with the Hobbit" and perhaps the first part of the LOTR trilogy, but not the remaining two.

xusiaxusia pro
2008-08-21 @ 21:17

That's an interesting point. Some people find the first umpteen chapters of "The Fellowship Of The Ring" hard (as this is set in the Shire) and don't feel the pace picks up until Aragorn turns up.

I, like yourself, have a strong affinity to "The Hobbit". I love the nature of Bilbo Bagiins and the old world feel of The Shire. I also like the material in TLOTR that takes place in the shire.

There are a few places in Kent where I live, that are unspoilt and free from modern day trappings. I find these areas of forest very Shire-like.

XoD.

ABE-unlimitedABE-unlimited pro
2008-08-22 @ 08:52

Precisely! I derived a great sense of peace and security when reading The Hobbit and The Fellowship of the Ring. It made me think of home (and I read them both when I lived in New Zealand - incidentally the HOME of Peter Jackson's TLOTR). It also made me think of far away, lost worlds of my childhood. There was a threat looming against those worlds and it is masterfullly conveyed by Tolkien in The Fellowship... But I just hated it when the threat became tangible in Two Towers.
And in the last part I felt lost on those great planes.
Er...let me know when I waffle too much.

i have to say i was a fan of lotr and the hobbit, the visuals in this film do seem very alien now! i don't think i will be watching this film. I like your review style btw

xusiaxusia pro
2008-08-21 @ 21:18

Thank you.

XoD.

kevinwilsonkevinwilson pro
2008-08-21 @ 21:33

i know i say this each time but it is true - you write good reviews!
thanks.

Leave a comment :

Your email address will not be displayed on this site.
Your URL will be displayed.
Allowed XHTML tags: <!, p, ul, ol, li, dl, dt, dd, address, blockquote, ins, del, a, span, bdo, br, em, strong, dfn, code, samp, kdb, var, cite, abbr, acronym, q, sub, sup, tt, i, b, big, small, img>
URLs, email, AIM and ICQs will be converted automatically.
Options:
 
(Line breaks become <br />)
(Set cookies for name, email & url)
Validation code:
Please enter the above code here:
For protection from spambots (case-sensitive).

Footer

The content of this website belongs to a private person, blog.co.uk is not responsible for the content of this website.